Department of Revenue

Honorable Finance Minister,

Even though there is clear cut policy and guideline for assessment under scrutiny that assessing officer can ask information only related to the points under which the case is selected under scrutiny.

My company case is selected for scrutiny for the FY 2012-13 at Mumbai. The assessing officer who is an IRS officer issued standard check list for providing information. On inquiring about the point for scrutiny it was informed that it was the amount of unsecured loan and loan providers. I agreed to provide all the information about the loan providers including the balances sheets, confirmations, etc. even though the loan was raised in former years. The same loan has been assessed under scrutiny in previous year so there is no need to do the exercise again.

Last year also i had complained to CBDT in the same case. The case was registered but was closed by Commissioner without inquiring into it.

On refusal to provide other details, he did not agreed and we had tough time.

Please issue a circular again and put it in press that no officer should ask for irrelevant details in assessment.

This becomes the ground for corruption and wastage of public money in poor administration.

*

The Central Board of Direct Taxes (CBDT) under Ministry of Finance has been showing enthusiasm in the initiation of Disciplinary Proceedings in respect of some of the Officers under its control but is now exhibiting same enthusiasm in the logical conclusions. It is violating all principles of Natural Justice, time bound schedule specified in the Vigilance Manual, does not review the progress of the pending cases, lack of interest in implementing discipline in the Inquiry Officers, Presenting Officers, Controller of Documents etc. It is also not learning from the outcome of such disciplinary proceedings in the sense that the lapses undergoing under its own nose by the supervisory authorities etc., and also failing in identifying the issues. Hence I rate the performance of this CBDT as below average.

------- Edited on 2016-01-15 -------

The CBDT is not honoring the verdicts of Hon'ble Supreme Court like the one where the Hon'ble Supreme Court had held as invalid of issue of a charge sheet without the approval of FM and had rejected the review petition and curative petition. When quoted this judgment in another case where similar charge sheet was issued without the approval of FM, the CBDT ignored the verdict of Supreme Court in spite of the fact of bringing it to its knowledge had re-issued same charge and validated the earlier non-est charge sheet. When pointed out to the PMO and RS of Finance Ministry no remedial help is being given. Can all people afford to go to High Court and Supreme Court filing contempt petitions? Who is going to give relief to the unfortunate charged officials? Can this forum do a little help?

Tax Reform Simplified,
Only 1% Tax on Receipt to get
more Taxpayers, Tax collections & more VOTES.

1) For Big Tax collections,
take 1% Tax from 20 Taxpayers,
than 20% Tax from one Taxpayer.

2) Simple Tax of 1% on Receipt /Transaction /Interest /Sale
/Gift /Loan /Benefit /Salary /Dividends /Rent /Custom.....
any & all inward cash, Cheque etc.

3) Average say on Rs. 30 L Receipt,
Pay Rs. 0.3 Lac Tax per year.
If Taxpayers = 60 Cr.
Tax collection will be 18 L- Cr.

4) Simple Tax means more Taxpayers, more collection & No refund Problem.

5) At present, we have say @ 3 Cr Taxpayers,
with Collection of say @ 3.5L-Cr,

6) So with 1% Tax, the Taxpayers will work to improve Business / Goods Services/ R.&D./
Social work.So more Employment, make in India, less Farmer Suicide & Peace of mind to the people.

7) Bank Account number is your mobile number.

8) Tax payment by your mobile number @ RBI a/c,
In bank transaction, the Bank will deposit your 1? Tax by your mobile number @ RBI a/c directly.

9) For cash Transaction pay similar to Post paid Mobile charges,
to your mobile number @ RBI a/c.
Most will pay if the Tax is 1% & simple to pay.

10) Your Bank Account Number should be mobile number & connected to PAN/ AADHAAR /Passport/ Election Card etc.
For Simplicity.

11) Tax collection will be distributed to State & Local bodies, say 10% each, from the place of collection.

12) Also add 1% more (L.P.F.)
Less Privilege Fund,
similar to PPF for,
social / self benefit,
to give Power to the people for Social Cause / in your bad days.

13) In short Pay Rs. 20- for every Rs. 1,000- Received.

i) Rs. 10- as tax to RBI
ii) Rs. 10- in your (L. P. F.) a/c. Could be use for social cause/ for your bad days.

14) L. P. F. (Less Privilege Fund)
of 18 L- Cr, with 60 Cr voters, will reduce dependency on the Government for the Social development.
Fund will be used for the Social cause / in your bad days.

15) Keep faith in 60 Cr voters, as they will take care of their neighbours, in need.
Also most will pay, if Tax is 1? & Simple to pay.
Only Indian can make better India.

16) Can consider more tax for Higher Receipt, say above 0.5 Cr per year, payable at the year ending.

17) All Transactions are Traceable as mobile number is once Bank a/c number & connected to PAN/ AADHAAR
/ Election card.....
So, No Corruption & Black Money Problem.

18) Babus Harassing the youth,
Traders, Voters.. who wants to work.
Babus are ruthless as they
pay "Protection Money" to......?
for Posting/ Promotion/ Permit...
Administrations Reform is a Must.
For getting Votes.

19) Farmers suicide can get reduced, by encouraging them to sell their farm products on Railways to commuter
& roads to motorists, also we need more Passenger Train, to help farmers to sell farm products, to nearby Towns.

20) Expecting Feedback on How to make India Peaceful Place by Refined, Simple Laws.
No blame game please.
Media/ Babus /Netas /Judicial Role is Eminent along with People.

For "Sare Jaha Se Achha Hindustan Hamara." Rate this message.