CLARIFICATION NEEDED DEPARTMENT OF CONSUMER AFFAIR

Following are the queries of members for which we seek clarification from the Dept. of consumer affairs :

Prashant Mohan July 8th Resource post .
GST on discounted price
Please see attached invoice from woodland shared with me by a friend. Authorities pf consumer dept Kindly confirm if this is a fair invoice or the consumer is being cheated .Attachment pertains to this.

X
Anil Kumar chat July 4th
I have purchased medicine from a dispensary located in MAX Hospital Bathinda today i.e. on 04th July 2017. MRP of Capsule T 3 is Rs. 164/-. But after addition of GST, it comes to Rs. 171.23. Accordingly, I have paid Rs. 171.23 against MRP of 164/-. I am in possession of the Cash Memo.
x
Chetan Sharma
A retail stores in ambala, haryana charged extra vat in addition to price of clothes I have bills of these store to verify this transaction .

Another attached bill dated in July had the details of tax for liquor . 10% Service tax , then SGST AND CGST on the service tax . This may be the old pattern of taxing coupled with GST ?
X

. for the following.:
1.The resource of Prashant Mohan :on GST on discounted prices with a bill attached July 8th Resource
What is the SGST 6% , CGST of 6O charged in this post .
CAN ANY ONE EXPLAIN WHAT IS CGST 6% & SGST 6% AS SEEN I THE BILL ATTACHED BY PRASHANT MOHAN . THIS IS APPEARED IN AN OFFICIAL BILL AND HAS GONE ON RECORD. CAN A TRADER CHARGE 2 GST 'S ? ONLY DEPT. OF CONSUMER AFFAIRS (GOVERNMENT OF INDIA) CAN GIVE A REPLY .
The questions / doubts by circle members on your Resource post Dept. of Consumer Affairs (Government of India)
Charging of VAT/GST above MRP: Inputs Sought. more

Helpful Weights, Measures and MRP Enforcement Jul 11

Viewed by 1279

View all 14 comments Below 14 comments

Shyam Shrivastava

[ ]( # ) [ ]( # ) Â [ ]( http://r.sigma-institute.website/mk/cl/f/22PPPPowO6UVSiBJCBy_fAJbHOhClI_umT2IHq5nbv4mXKXFmMa__ANf_ipVitJV7sO_F-Mj2DU--BdUu8rttVdw1EyUE5aOkRVAx9Lab9IktQVjRZ3C1Si8q_5elBKNF19wupgoJZYtl8N3drfUVBu9PSItYR-SAom-COKGPIEk88NrLBfz7vkp1aCYj-IKM-8nZFwrc_qvAFvGaDPAcntGVxoEkMRGA-245O95V8kOunPcDQaxqb3NeJ0bSP5OAg7IniA24Okm_Ii4lz-IfjCIIxbW_yPU4jeJf8vZbDqAW6_z89tzgTzA1G5upwUfXusDqd-4Hu2DTC5mjNKXTbqtUMGQtvVPaNvVFZiggZtJ86jIyw ) Â [ ]( # ) COMPUTER FOR ONLINE CLASSES [ ]( # ) [ ]( http://r.sigma-institute.website/mk/cl/f/5OT665tQiwCN9yZBCYzlP_7kY2zGdFhS3UhEvSe7Dm6hbokUHLR4ZJFYrMWSFuwjqtNkCQtYR4zyE-x7OGx7S9MBQd7Ufn0SVfEtlc5zzBi_33Ehg1u1jlJD1wcC8ff8h2jYShwuhBuxqZfw0jLkRA2NEdYyoPDe5M5uFYOaXRW1Od2-jJjS3WwF_es57dTsCcD1GpL6diACMH2N3apYYgPlpKa9S2Evwm-VUe-iuhSjtf8inRRVb-37KKgIZY59Doct9j6qOIPZ7l_aBzL4-FdZcGXr_8Oui0E5Sc9r26rYkW6jzJv-qaoumyRZ3PBsKhIaOfGy_x47hCtl6SPYAUwmRWV-TKUhpKqAipi-gZQNhddIKA ) [ ]( # ) Â For online classes we are providing a complete set of computer with UPS in following specifications: Monitor 15"; Camera & headphone CPU: 160 GB HDD, 2 GB RAM, Core 2 duo Keyboard, mouse UPS ( Electronic voltage stabilizer ) This complete set we offer pan India for Rs. 21000/- ( All inclusive ) One extra 160 GB Hard disk will be supplied free of cost within 5 years, if present becomes in sufficient. All carry "M.I.'s" 1 year warranty. Â Â Â [ ]( # ) [ ]( http://r.sigma-institute.website/mk/cl/f/bPJWY62OuAL3AnrJW5-bqjWITT1WJUhe0V4mM0oS0NfiUhooxLNGq8a1ou9uxlvucOc8X38kvAld2yCjlyBv8hAfHt3pgjZeenevBmFRrY_nSFjaHj6a2A0kMNAEEnsYiL9j5lOvWDG_90327ZWQluBCu37cjWMs82kaaV07UoOIZfMm8LJECqXqseRKu0yrI7Pyp0hflZ2ijJuDAB4JpxRWoOvkDYiMZoWpKzO9JnvJqcD5ssXWqceqCbsg6Et3d1VCQh1WckwHbUms1vmvhTyqTszJdlwMc5oiJ-an-MWSjVSc64C1RwvpCsakoQYubAU1-d27u_GCSEMzHq-Rcq0VIrQI0Yoy6W5yoSWPo9QIt5jSpA ) We understand the hardships... Â Hardships of the parents, hardships of teachers, hardships of every such individual who is now compelled to work from home; be it student or the the professional now computer set is must. we decided to help all such people by providing the complete set including UPS to save your machine for longer life. In comparison to laptops desktop is robust & longÂ lasting and also cheap & best ! For getting this deal, please click the button below: Â [ Button ]( http://r.sigma-institute.website/mk/cl/f/4WSn07TV_A48JQ2vo-pelng17KOAPFoG_WAvOFqpkkttrEbq9QqYSLw2dK4iDCD5k3TsFxw0mGfAlTdtjAfxQ0IY-uugr2xtgYMBGmbcYOlxQlfdxPWZTWMzgMjw6TO3xU9DVzByR8bMQ8q73MF-gQfZ-CmnemZqr8vX6z4yNV7GnxSS7BtFFwmQOS3B_FhtaAWz-RJGOJlwMTQr61Y3tjMLomNYbAzr19hYQtfGK8Ejd90oDp9X7XzBo5KcK8R7wmZGUh1wiDwZ1t3EW9KAOOZ33_XfDtDgsjV9U07q89jOS_zKK5FX0jWvWwcpR8pliljqrt5AR8ufyL9NBG5zloFrL5mGUlT1Y5Gnw6_COGt8L8MFNg ) [ ]( # ) [ ]( # ) Â SIGMA INSTITUTE Delhi Cell: 9899075161 [ ]( http://r.sigma-institute.website/mk/cl/f/qGrNkoqoKSF4s6Rmg9PQ6JCct7be5D4SCtUNkMB7pgb9iJmdJ9FmgXYz32EOgAcoBkUuejzXkyDshpcEMqoBOrIzrWcHc16D-dgkx6G857EM8nuAj5ysmINQpnnRXaUdJfeRopqOrKmKNqFyRVM1tv3dZiD8jnAXgil7sz9Cg43FTyOY3flmJIeQ87tty2mgfdW5JyOXpIX_o7Nz7dhWehLK-OSspD-vHPgOCaEyqL67emqAASfSPHpUY4MlK397uMwzSSC_NMvFcbBtYH-Ouv1q47z_RilrymFn84f-uGyPXOFhWKtl3Lq8ug6H3gGqGvBr4WrWvLH9bxTRPZxBy35y4bfe0w ) [ ]( http://r.sigma-institute.website/mk/cl/f/OYEsirng2zHYB-Ze3NN-4a0P9u6NOveBUbJbTdG-lD-xUBTL5XawZdQLfzSvwTeJh1NNWndsThba9L2evfhKf60QJI9hSgSL73Tg5Oj6FT1YPEV4V0fC1kqYtdn4nVI7zBpey_mzxSWa0xQDi7AjO-8mjFFXLyLmr-fa6Egqoemfxi8qMsJzywpbs0LW_51RatYOs7HWk276DjHsQ293vgylxs-9sHzzCznMONAl_8II9u9lfy8P6f7JrAZ8uBD3i0x742jwx7anaEXFgK-Dkz-zlnEt6mqGxVnGhRkb10Szr80Hd0LD1PH61VLN6OvEpL_2V8nludhSjpfqOJazMV-0RA ) [ ]( http://r.sigma-institute.website/mk/cl/f/zPn5lFQ1T-Ln07Yh86cC3Yl0FVFqmfCXuoRAjOPVrkBEuxz9EAld6ooesa3EvfRp-X9oOXTBOuZZl8Hpiz0m4c5amONi8jWhWiIbDqHZwhBNBaViY47N9JNvNMTOGgA906WXRDvUdrfhN3GbX2mERzFtUWTVvl9EUgRFT3KvW17xzkBW2umaQrnpzBVvLdCAUfjiyC78PTqAJAR2HGge4Y9PkZx2JfOdb_3U4IOsejtHPVRxqLHIh_GBRBmPf08mvNa9s5a4EpPAeRp9x2UO3jo_nBqJI6cOiITChURL3gs3tAD2PHy512FBS4g0gm49cZmLmggI2Hf3fb_QABBgXOs ) [ ]( http://r.sigma-institute.website/mk/cl/f/0m4nf4HixffU4XVyOZACRcD4nx2Kergf6tJ94AcgvtOloLvqGKeji0lJ44gFU6P4-Km3Juo4XNGfQDaEp5yg44LnRV7svoKc6cVz_RkZTcOFlrJyEhdXh2k1USTXp5KWgK7_py7vMuT54-8s82-TqhuExqxRqO2TiIjRZoxjWYO-JZNWjVUsI4SRVmEyCTUNPi039CJ9o76_qEa7ajxMwi_OPiKiWg-QnvkAhga6SO-dTPaMih-T3ezSe20P25bBkv_Cn_TQ7515vKhdFgb-SFaz9WPVy3EQ1mpBaOO6uinAqSTiiNum-4NJSflZpYiSaPYVPY6e58ecLDr8iMfKeLzyV5GZ96neZfXFdRo ) [ ]( http://r.sigma-institute.website/mk/cl/f/hq4WxTZeSUFXKvxjJuNW-EbB1itzDhXdsIRMIhM_NsD-xm515fSLVUGDobXbqY8xeB3EH12T82i2OY-LuP2ldg_1oAVds6b8dQT--oHHq4x6Z5oGh4aqL6vi-ClHaDiAQBjjHoeMxzJLTOOmR5J0bfuUBUvBJsbL2-1bcRJUwKss6V_c4k3hnfFaCY4-LXUFD763tP-mTYMb3rGjLJi5Y_p0TgvmGT3aiaQGjtAOuE6YgbZI7PBXdsy3Nm3hxPskJO7IO3qgMhpD5ySGgpTRFAaAHWVb0UU6NFcCB5xIXa9TNimpg0x9eVwkKSzeMcJ-gDhgaRxnbRMliuuHhOSVrVdag9s06g ) [ ]( http://r.sigma-institute.website/mk/cl/f/QumDLt2S0GxTNd04XHkOHaGUJK3le96_siCxN3OPij86_UzJiHwUKsed4ki_PUbqFJPUobMPHznZLiUgdUPgRbYBbEMsDc-GDhhl7tNZJ1JP--oGhhFTxsnYxb5Tj_hZxlW2Lyqenfe9oZ4DpAc5jbCy30OnK-19qi2JCvFIsT0deBKNSoSQIMBwsWxDOtEkbpNm5_tcjf8zOOugiPWoPhonuNB3e7ixmmV9WCSMmH0b_tyCxdMUgOJy-NdvVtSKgfEH8cuo2JX0SbKNo666QhTV7jfle-KBKM36ZnCt5NMpcChIR-Z66CFhXFOPwEuakUoFYalsX8sjj8tWDAo8qDgOv5OVLP_M_qSbCbU4reIMwkCZqT40V6uazkNBgj1RKU2Ocb3h56AEhykQHjU ) [ ]( http://r.sigma-institute.website/mk/cl/f/Q5QBUoQIt-RcKnTyQtvVzWpDFtGGaWm8RBD2d6dsKnv6mrSybdgxX77YF_xvw1TenaUaoLurnl2beOYJNYWQ-LGFtiVi8Kw2bxf9eFTzLzwLgMseAdZOqvGvX6sxNqUodhEBgZ8bLjgdu2mJu25GNisewNGRHsIn9TCyUAfjPZqKQNjivBBzuGfV0x_3IRtoVy4Fq379-g2yupOkTHF2KzFM-mHGpzhYb1deJOEA4gaVFOhaGeO-_cGwME1zbF_yxCv41RqBAPqxf4jpSzXaPBsTB8u4PxbR0s7D19y_sdBs7EKxDo23TmupU3ip2h8FHyZtmtduar7FZv_TfCpE9e10MSeX0ir8BjDsuoyW ) [ ]( http://r.sigma-institute.website/mk/cl/f/4qt5fNbLsO1T-0IC2Yfpe8jga34jXCjqreR0CzXuVtNI_iND4fp7aCO2x1GAVqqamvoaOyHr-vHAUR_xAYnoNgwSES9AIXFWjGZlV2Blj8LhrVmtD5Sk4ZAS3FswGn_Qq_LRmAvM3zElG3Q8JgXOOI1pE1Hnl2bK_jWFvZtcGyen_Ed7yBBZYzRqEXeIcyJ-PeJVpXWSnJ3FPGdcgEF1dlOgpK8s0RMBru_-3CImFv9A7_Y7Q59Swjjg14h4oKaNDzopW3ke4WropFcdmU9452J7tENcqwIBV2YtboWh_jHVbm4qt3rnHxbko-vXBt6URqm_plCb9CBQt_1a9aX6K9yKoTNKKl_2UINd ) Â [ ]( # ) Â You received this email because you are registered with Sigma Institute Â [ Unsubscribe here ]( http://r.sigma-institute.website/mk/un/Ye_SMU-MJYErZYos-8xbAXuPBjSEbY3TDnt_64qdRqyy_zThyggl4hZF35fey-enUpGp-kYB3mX-ipZW4UTu7Cru_gG-l_MFZ0wPb9uONkmpJphi9NQKNFLxIkQijsTPnGIxMhtHkjrtORSCbZtdnW1qMFO7xuQMMLTdBSUN92r2WKH1NLqu0StnHqu_fKT2GnFhFjJB_OCVglJRvouoRpgqKp0 ) Â [ ]( # ) Â Â© 2020 Sigma Institute Â more

Oct 31

Gopabandhu Mohapatra

Many people of the business community are taking advantage of the confusion in implementation of GST. Let government clarify the matter in simple terms in reputed newspapers. more

Jul 13

Ranjit Biswas

As per clarifications being given in daily news papers on different aspects of GST, the tax (GST) being charged in a bill is required to be equally payable to both the State Government & Central Government and required to be bifurcated as SGST (State GST) and CGST (Central GST) in the bill itself. The total tax payable will, however, remain the rate specified for a particular product. Accordingly, the sellers will deposit the aggregate tax collected for each government in their respective accounts. Charging any kind of other taxes, viz, sales tax, VAT etc. after introduction of GST is completely illegal. more

Jul 13

Vishwanath Kaushik

Why such a complicated law wherein a number of documents have to be generated and preserved and so many returns to be filed throughout the year. Whether the business people should concentrate on their business and go on bothering filing so many returns to diff authorities. Everything boils down to CONSUMPTION. WHY NOT HAVE ONE SIMPLE CONSUMPTION (based mainly on withdrawals of sums from the bank--almost all of us withdraw money from the Bank for spending). Now Banks have enormous sums lying with them as Deposits. Individuals/business draw money to meet their own requirements.Why not have a TDS starting from as low as 1% going up to 10% or so such that will generate a fund of more than 30-40 lakh crores (more than the total revenue generated at all levels). If felt necessary enable the State governments to have powers to levy similar TDS based rate if they so desire. Please think it over. = vishwanathan sviss38@yahoo.com more

Jul 13

AA JOSE

This Government has not only left loopholes for cheating common man/consumers as has been rightly pointed out by Shri. HP Agrawalji and others, but more alarming is the fact that lives of several people have also been put to risk. A recent "Whatsup" message sent by a friend from Kerala State is reproduced hereunder to illustrate this: Quote: "URGENT ATTENTION OF SUGAR PATIENTS!" "My name is Vadakkan Lonappan Jacob residing at Cheloor, Irinjalakuda, Kerala. I am a severe Sugar patient and is under insuline treatment. I regret to inform all concerned that insuline has disappeared from the market, specially Human Mixard, which is the most common brand being prescribed by Doctors. I am in the market for insuline since last few days, but not available. Shopkeepers says that they are not getting the stocks due to non-finalisation of GST Tarrif and they are not aware when they will get. Stock is actually available with Consumer Fed, as I understand from Shopkeepers, but not passing the same to shopkeepers due to again GST Tarrif." "Under the circumstances what will happen to the patients, those who are under Insuline treatment. Now only Insuline not available, but tomorrow all other related medicines will disappear. Who will take the responsibility if somebody dies due to non-availability of Insuline.? Therefore, my humble request is to share this message to all your friends and groups until it reaches to the responsible authority, forcing them to take urgent steps, so that Insuline and other related medicines are made available in the market. All groups are requested to further share it so that the message will reach to the higher ups very fast........Jacob Vadakkan - 11th July,2017." ....Unquote From the above, one can make out the pathetic situation faced by people on the haphazard manner of implementation of the GST in the country without proper planning, preparation and safeguards to see that common man is not burdened further and that such hardships may not arise atleast for essential drugs and other items. more

Jul 13

View 14 more comment(s)