Delhi belongs to India
In the past couple of days, the Delhi Government has suspended two DANICS (Civil Service) Officers, on the ground that they refused to authenticate and release for implementation a couple of Orders of the State Government. The Civil Services Officers Association of the Delhi Government promptly met, expressed their indignation at the step taken (without legal jurisdiction according to the association), and went on 'mass half-day leave' (largely successful) for one day, the 31 December. An incensed Chief Minister of Delhi branded the Civil Servants as "full-fledged B-Team of BJP”, and issued a warning that the bureaucrats be replaced by 'experts'; further fulminating that he will "not tolerate IAS goondaism”. It should be noted that these events took place immediately ahead of the major anti-pollution 'odd-even vehicle entry' drive which commenced in Delhi on 1 January 2016, on a 15-day experimental basis.
A senior Civil Servant strike is a very rare event; one does not recall IAS officers going on strike, en masse, in any state or in GoI, in the past 68 years. Clearly the senior Delhi Civil Servants have felt constricted and squeezed between the Kejriwal Government and the Centre, and their current action – token absence for one day – is a declaration of extreme distress. Promptly, the state political leadership blamed the officials for muddying the waters, and complicating life for the administration prior to a major event (odd-even vehicle-entry experiment) – it could equally be pointed out that it was highly insensitive of the Delhi Administration to suspend two officers at this juncture; and a demonstration of their naivety, inexperience and lack of governance acumen not to anticipate the reaction from the senior bureaucracy.
It is also necessary to go to the background to get the full picture. Delhi is a Union Territory (like 6 others – Chandigarh, Andaman, etc.), administered by the Centre directly, under constitutional provisions – the authority of the Centre being exercised by the Lt. Governor or the Administrator as the case may be. The DANICS cadre is shared between Delhi State and Andaman & Nicobar Islands – the Cadre is not exclusive to Delhi, the Cadre authority being the Home Ministry. The UT Cadre of the IAS is shared by all the Union Territories, as also by some full-fledged states like Goa, Arunachal. For the past many decades, no question has arisen disputing the fact that DANICS / UT Cadre IAS is totally controlled by the Home Ministry, with posting and transfer powers, as well as disciplinary Cadre Controlling authority; this is the factual position on the ground. If the new Delhi Government disputes this position, it is for them to sort it out with the Centre (Home Ministry), or go to the Supreme Court for a clarification.
A unilateral declaration by Kejriwal that he is the master of all that he surveys, and that he has unbounded power and authority to do 'whatever is good for Delhi', and 'root out corruption', may indicate a certain unacceptable level of self-aggrandisement , not borne out by the legal and constitutional position. In the face of repeated orders by the Home Ministry and the Delhi LG that the senior officers are under the ultimate administrative control of the Government of India in this Union Territory, it is extremely unfair to treat the civil service cadres as political football, and force them to choose between orders of the GoI or the State. Clearly the officers are caught in the cross-fire; Kejriwal cannot declare a neutral civil servant as 'enemy'. For the failure of Kejriwal to obtain a clear ruling from the competent authority in India about his control over the DANICS / IAS Officers in Delhi, the latter should not be chastised.
By very nature, senior civil servants are not to be seen or heard, nor are they expected to be 'political'. To categorize the entire group of civil servants as stooges of BJP is not only factually irresponsible, but also highly short-sighted; exhibits inability to keep the morale of Delhi officers high, demonstrating total lack of administrative vision. The officialdom is an instrument to be used for governance by the political leadership; calling them names, and alienating them with absurd, non-provable, baseless allegations will be highly counter-productive. This raises the suspicion whether the state government is seriously interested in governance, or is merely raising dust at every pretext – Don Quixote forever tilting at windmills!
One can think of no country in the world, of any governance description (monarchy, democracy, dictatorship, army rule etc.) which is being governed without 'bureaucrats'. If an 'expert' continues in government service for any length of time, he will be termed a 'bureaucrat'; the generalist – specialist argument is age-old. Surely Kejriwal does not have the experience, background, wisdom or the moral right to prescribe a national governance model; he has just moved from 'rabble-rouser' status to 'non-governing' Chief Minister position of a municipal area – surely he should wait a little bit to tell India how it is to be governed. Nobody argues with the need for major reform, but this should not be triggered or caused solely because one man is peeved.
In recent weeks, Kejriwal has furnished clear evidence why it was a mistake to allow an 'elected' Assembly in Delhi. The Union Government, Constitutional and statutory bodies, and the apex judiciary are located there; what happens in Delhi is important to every Indian – that is why it is a Union Territory and not a state. Given the way irresponsible State and Regional leaders often behave to further their own political interests, it will be extremely dangerous to think of handing over the police administration and 'land' matters to the Delhi State – this is the norm for a full-fledged state, and Delhi demands full-fledged Statehood. An immature politician can rapidly bring chaos to administration in Delhi, which will affect national stability. The current reality is that Delhi Government has even less powers than Brahan Mumbai Municipality or Puducherry (a Union Territory). At an early appropriate political juncture, national interest will demand the permanent termination of Delhi's assembly, to treat it like other Union Territories, under the direct administration of the Government of India. The tail should not be allowed to wag the dog. Delhi belongs to India. more
A senior Civil Servant strike is a very rare event; one does not recall IAS officers going on strike, en masse, in any state or in GoI, in the past 68 years. Clearly the senior Delhi Civil Servants have felt constricted and squeezed between the Kejriwal Government and the Centre, and their current action – token absence for one day – is a declaration of extreme distress. Promptly, the state political leadership blamed the officials for muddying the waters, and complicating life for the administration prior to a major event (odd-even vehicle-entry experiment) – it could equally be pointed out that it was highly insensitive of the Delhi Administration to suspend two officers at this juncture; and a demonstration of their naivety, inexperience and lack of governance acumen not to anticipate the reaction from the senior bureaucracy.
It is also necessary to go to the background to get the full picture. Delhi is a Union Territory (like 6 others – Chandigarh, Andaman, etc.), administered by the Centre directly, under constitutional provisions – the authority of the Centre being exercised by the Lt. Governor or the Administrator as the case may be. The DANICS cadre is shared between Delhi State and Andaman & Nicobar Islands – the Cadre is not exclusive to Delhi, the Cadre authority being the Home Ministry. The UT Cadre of the IAS is shared by all the Union Territories, as also by some full-fledged states like Goa, Arunachal. For the past many decades, no question has arisen disputing the fact that DANICS / UT Cadre IAS is totally controlled by the Home Ministry, with posting and transfer powers, as well as disciplinary Cadre Controlling authority; this is the factual position on the ground. If the new Delhi Government disputes this position, it is for them to sort it out with the Centre (Home Ministry), or go to the Supreme Court for a clarification.
A unilateral declaration by Kejriwal that he is the master of all that he surveys, and that he has unbounded power and authority to do 'whatever is good for Delhi', and 'root out corruption', may indicate a certain unacceptable level of self-aggrandisement , not borne out by the legal and constitutional position. In the face of repeated orders by the Home Ministry and the Delhi LG that the senior officers are under the ultimate administrative control of the Government of India in this Union Territory, it is extremely unfair to treat the civil service cadres as political football, and force them to choose between orders of the GoI or the State. Clearly the officers are caught in the cross-fire; Kejriwal cannot declare a neutral civil servant as 'enemy'. For the failure of Kejriwal to obtain a clear ruling from the competent authority in India about his control over the DANICS / IAS Officers in Delhi, the latter should not be chastised.
By very nature, senior civil servants are not to be seen or heard, nor are they expected to be 'political'. To categorize the entire group of civil servants as stooges of BJP is not only factually irresponsible, but also highly short-sighted; exhibits inability to keep the morale of Delhi officers high, demonstrating total lack of administrative vision. The officialdom is an instrument to be used for governance by the political leadership; calling them names, and alienating them with absurd, non-provable, baseless allegations will be highly counter-productive. This raises the suspicion whether the state government is seriously interested in governance, or is merely raising dust at every pretext – Don Quixote forever tilting at windmills!
One can think of no country in the world, of any governance description (monarchy, democracy, dictatorship, army rule etc.) which is being governed without 'bureaucrats'. If an 'expert' continues in government service for any length of time, he will be termed a 'bureaucrat'; the generalist – specialist argument is age-old. Surely Kejriwal does not have the experience, background, wisdom or the moral right to prescribe a national governance model; he has just moved from 'rabble-rouser' status to 'non-governing' Chief Minister position of a municipal area – surely he should wait a little bit to tell India how it is to be governed. Nobody argues with the need for major reform, but this should not be triggered or caused solely because one man is peeved.
In recent weeks, Kejriwal has furnished clear evidence why it was a mistake to allow an 'elected' Assembly in Delhi. The Union Government, Constitutional and statutory bodies, and the apex judiciary are located there; what happens in Delhi is important to every Indian – that is why it is a Union Territory and not a state. Given the way irresponsible State and Regional leaders often behave to further their own political interests, it will be extremely dangerous to think of handing over the police administration and 'land' matters to the Delhi State – this is the norm for a full-fledged state, and Delhi demands full-fledged Statehood. An immature politician can rapidly bring chaos to administration in Delhi, which will affect national stability. The current reality is that Delhi Government has even less powers than Brahan Mumbai Municipality or Puducherry (a Union Territory). At an early appropriate political juncture, national interest will demand the permanent termination of Delhi's assembly, to treat it like other Union Territories, under the direct administration of the Government of India. The tail should not be allowed to wag the dog. Delhi belongs to India. more
Viewed by 1855
View all 41 comments Below 41 comments
Well, we call ourselves an "Educated Minority" in India and then indulge in silly discussions... Let's think rationally - 1. Why should Modi not call for a meeting with Arvind and listen to his genuine issues to help & support AAP to run the show efficiently? 2. Why Governor not co-operate with elected Govt to perform well,in the interest of Delhi Public? 3. Why Delhi Public should not 'Wholeheartedly' Support every initiative of AAP to make Delhi a better place to live? 4. Why all CORRUPT & UNCOUTH element of Society & Political Parties are missing their LOOT since AAP is in Action? So, please try and understand "DEEP-ROOTED CONSPIRACY" to FAIL AAP at the COST of DENHI PUBLIC ... BE AWARE and FIRMLY SUPPORT ELECTED GOVT in GOOD GOVERNANCE, PLEASE! more
Jan 11
Mr Guha ,so it is alright for you that so called king of crusader against corruption can by pass his principe just to stop Modiji because he is leading India to a place where you can not even think becuase of your narrowmind set to be happy with free water. Pray tell me what great chages Kejriwal has made in delhi. And why is he only after Aryn Jaitelyji and not after Shiela Dixit. The answer is obvious . Kejriwal has to stop development by Modiji by hook or by crook. more
Jan 09
"Mr Vinod Kumar, BLIND PERSONS CANNOT WITNESS THE CHANGES MADE IN DELHI BY AAP GOVT, & BENEFITING THE MASSES. ALSO I AM 2 REMIND U AGAIN THAT BIHARIS PREFERRED A FODDER SCAM ACCUSED TO MODI. AND STILL U R WONDERING WHY AK HUGGED LALU? I ALSO THANK DELHITITES 4 SUPPORTING ODD/EVEN CAR RATIONING, & MAKING IT A GREAT SUCCESS AGAINST ALL D OPPOSITION BY BJP & CONGRESS & A FEW CHAMCHAS OF THEM. PETROL, DIESEL SALE DOWN BY 40%. LESSER TRAFFIC JAMS SO LESSER IDLING TIME OF VEHICLES IN DELHI ROADS. more
Jan 09
Mr Guha what do you have to say on hugging scam master laloo. What has kejriwal done so far other than fighting with Centre. more
Jan 08
Mr Vinod Kumar, U HAVE NO CHOICE BUT TO DIGEST THE REJECTION/HUMILIATION OF MODI BY DELHITIES (03/70) & BIHARIS(53/243). MODI'S CHAMCHHAs HAS 2 BEAR THIS HUMILIATION, THEY HAVE NO CHOICE, NOR CAN THEY REVERSE THE GROUND REALITY. WORST DAYS AHEAD FOR MODI IN THE ENSUING ASSEMBLY POLLS IN DIFFERENT STATES. WHOM SHOULD MODI CHAMCHHAS BLAME THEN? "FOR BLIND FOLLOWERS OF MODI, I ONCE AGAIN SUBMIT MODI's ACHIEVEMENTS IN 19 MONTHS: 1) 60 महीनों में से 19 महीने बीत चुके मोदी सरकार बने यानी 31% से ज्यादा समय बीत चुका है तो जनता सवाल क्यों न करे सरकार से? 2) ये लोकतंत्र है यानी जनता का शासन जिसमें प्रधानमंत्री जनता का सेवक होता है तो जनता क्यों सवाल न करे अपने प्रधान सेवक से कि भाई क्या-क्या किया अब तक और किस के हित में किया इसकी रिपोर्ट दो? 3) जनता क्यों सवाल न करे कि जो मोदी जी डॉलर के मुक़ाबले रुपये की कीमत 35 पर लाने का दावा करते थे उनके 19 माह के कार्यकाल में ही डॉलर के मुक़ाबले रुपये की कीमत 26मई2014 के 58•755 से कीमत 14% गिर कर 67 तक कैसे पहुँच गई? 4) जनता क्यों न पूछे कि पाकिस्तान को उसी की भाषा में जवाब देने, उसके साथ शांति समझौतों को \"लव-लैटर\" कह कर विरोध करने वाले मोदी जी की प्रमुख सहयोगी और हेमराज के एक सिर के बदले पाकिस्तान के दस सिर लाने का दावा करने वाली सरकार की विदेश मंत्री आख़िर 19 महीनों में ही ये बयान क्यों दे रही है कि \"युद्ध समस्या का हल नहीं है\" और क्यों अब वो पाकिस्तान के विदेश मंत्री के साथ हँसते-गुनगुनाते हाथों में हाथ डाले डिनर कर रही है तब जब पाक सेना के हमले बढ़ गए हैं? 5) जनता क्यों न पूछे कि स्वदेशी का राग अलापने वाले लोगों की सरकार शिक्षा को भी डब्लूटीओ के माध्यम से विदेशी सौदागरों के हवाले क्यों कर रही है? 6) जनता क्यों न पूछे कि 2014 के लोकसभा चुनावों से पहले तक एफ़डीआई का विरोध करने वाले लोगों ने सरकार बनने के 19 महीनों में ही रक्षा,बीमा,रेलवे जैसे 15 क्षेत्रों में 49% से ले कर 100% तक एफ़डीआई क्यों पहुँचा दी? 7) जनता क्यों न पूछे कि महँगाई क्यों बढ़ रही है, दाल ₹200\/किग्रा तक कैसे बढ़ रही है? 8) जनता क्यों न पूछे कि पहले से ही जो एजूकेशन बजट मात्र 3•1% था उसमें से भी ₹10हज़ार करोड़ क्यों घटाए? 9) जनता क्यों न पूछे कि विदेशी दवा कंपनियों के दवाब में मोदी सरकार ने कैंसर जैसी घातक बीमारियों के इलाज के लिए मिलने वाली जीवनरक्षक दवाइयों की कीमत13 गुना तक क्यों बढ़ा दी? 10) जनता क्यों न पूछे कि अंतर्राष्ट्रीय बाजार में कच्चे तेल की कीमतों में 70% तक की गिरावट आने के बावजूद पैट्रोल की कीमत उस अनुपात में क्यों नहीं घटाई गईं? 11) जनता क्यों न पूछे कि जिन भारतीय कॉर्पोरेट्स ने सरकारी बैंकों से कर्ज 7 लाख करोड़ रुपए का कर्ज़ लिया हुआ है मगर चुका नहीं रहे उन पर दवाब बना कर वो रुपया निकलवाने की बजाय अडानी जैसे अपने दोस्त को ऑस्ट्रेलिया में व्यापार के लिए 1अरब डॉलर का अनैतिक लोन क्यों दिलवाया और कॉर्पोरेट टैक्स को और घटा कर ऐसे लोगों को और फायदा क्यों दिया खासकर तब जब किसान कर्ज के चलते रिकॉर्ड संख्या में आत्महत्या कर रहे हैं? 12) जनता क्यों न पूछे कि पूरी दुनिया घूम कर रईसों से मिलने वाले मोदी जी को 19 महीनों में एक भी बार आत्महत्या को मजबूर हो रहे किसानों से मिलने और उनको मदद देने की फुरसत क्यों न मिली? 13) जनता क्यों न पूछे कि बीते 19 महीनों में मोदी सरकार ने कितने रोजगार दिए कि रोजगार सूचकांक निगेटिव में चला गया? 14) जनता क्यों न पूछे कि\"100दिन में सारा काला धन वापस न ले आऊँ तो मुझे फाँसी पर लटका देना\" जैसे बयान दे कर जनता को बरगलाने वाले मोदी जी अब 577 दिन में एक रुपए का भी काला धन क्यों नहीं लाए? 15) जनता क्यों न पूछे कि स्वच्छ भारत अभियान का हाल अब तक ऐसा क्यों है कि खुद मोदी जी के गोद लिए गाँव जयापुरा में सांसद आदर्श ग्राम योजना के तहत बने 600 टॉयलेट्स में से एक में भी पानी का कनैक्शन नहीं है, 7 टूट चुके, कई अधबने हैं, अधिकांश में अंदर से बंद करने को चटकनी नहीं है और टैंक की गहराई महज कुछ फुट है? जब पीएम के गोद लिए गाँव के हालात ऐसे हैं तो देश के बाकी गाँवों की क्या हालत होगी ये समझा जा सकता है। 16) जनता क्यों न पूछे कि 100 करोड़ का विज्ञापन स्वच्छ भारत मिशन के लिए करने के बावजूद मथुरा जैसे शहर (जहाँ सांसद और नगर पालिका अध्यक्षा भाजपा की हैं) में पब्लिक टॉयलेट्स क्यों नहीं हैं? 17) जनता क्यों न पूछे कि \"बहुत हुआ नारी पर वार,अबकी बार ……\" और \"बेटी बचाओ-बेटी पढ़ाओ\" जैसे नारे देने वाली सरकार अपनी पुलिस के माध्यम से सस्ती शिक्षा का अधिकार माँग रही बेटियों की हड्डियाँ क्यों तुड़वाती है और सिर क्यों फोड़ती है और बलात्कार के आरोपी निहालचंद जैसे आदमी को कैबीनेट मंत्री क्यों बना के रखती है? 18) जनता क्यों न पूछे कि 6 महीने के अंदर संसद से दागी सांसदों को हटा देने की कसमें खाने वाले मोदी जी ने अब तक दागी सांसदों के खिलाफ कोई कदम क्यों नहीं उठाया? 19) जनता क्यों न पूछे कि लोकसभा चुनाव की प्रचार सभाओं में रॉबर्ट वाड्रा के खिलाफ लच्छेदार डायलॉग बोल कर जनता को रिझा कर तालियाँ पिटवाने वाले मोदीजी ने 19 महीने बाद भी हरियाणा में और केन्द्र में भाजपा सरकार होने के बावजूद रॉबर्ट वाड्रा को क्यों नहीं पकड़वाया? 20) जनता क्यों न पूछे कि मोदी सरकार के प्रमुख प्रचारक \"अच्छे दिन\" लाने के अपने वादों को \"चुनावी जुमला\" क्यों बता रहे हैं और मोदी जी इस पर ख़ामोश क्यों हैं? 21) जनता क्यों न पूछे कि गुजरात की शराबबंदी (जहाँ ब्लैक में सबसे ज्यादा शराब बिकती है) दिखा कर जनता से वोट माँगने वाले के शासन में देश में शराब की बिक्री क्यों बढ़ गई? 22) जनता क्यों न पूछे कि बीफ़ एक्सपोर्ट के लिए काँग्रेस की बुराई कर भोले शाकाहारियों से वोट बटोरने वाले मोदी जी के राज में भारत बीफ़ एक्सपोर्ट में विश्व में टॉप पर क्यों आ गया है? Hibiscusजिस पार्टी के पुरखों ने स्वतंत्रता संग्राम में कोई योगदान नहीं दिया वे देशभक्ति की परिभाषा तय कर रहे हैंHibiscus Hibiscusजिनके राजनैतिक पुरखों ने अंग्रेजों से लिखित माफ़ी माँगी और देशभक्त साथियों की मुखबिरी की वे हमारे देशप्रेम का हिसाब माँग रहे हैंHibiscus Hibiscusसनी लीयोनी की जैसों की पॉर्न सटार की फिल्म पर चूँ तक न करने वाले (क्योंकि खुद ऐसी फिल्म देखते हैं) सांस्कृतिक राष्ट्रवाद के नाम पर अन्य साफ़-सुथरी फिल्मों के पोस्टर फाड़ रहे हैंHibiscus BouquetBouquetBouquet कोई आदमी बंपर जीत के 19 महीनों के अंदर ही इतना अलोकप्रिय हो जाता है कि अरबों-खरबों रुपये के खर्चे के साथ इस पीएम के निचले स्तर तक का चुनाव प्रचार करने के बावजूद 19 महीने के अंदर ही- दिल्ली में भाजपा हारीSmiling face with open mouth बिहार में भाजपा हारीSmiling face with open mouth केरल में भाजपा हारीSmiling face with open mouth त्रिपुरा में भाजपा हारीSmiling face with open mouth यूपी में भाजपा हारीSmiling face with open mouth कश्मीर में भाजपा हारीSmiling face with open mouth मोदी जी के गृह-राज्य गुजरात में भाजपा हारीSmiling face with open mouth मोदी जी के गाँव में भाजपा हारीSmiling face with open mouth मोदी जी के संसदीय क्षेत्र के आदर्श ग्राम में भाजपा हारीSmiling face with open mouth Face with stuck-out tongue and winking eyeFace with stuck-out tongue and winking eyeFace with stuck-out tongue and winking eyeआख़िर कुछ तो खोट होंगे बंदे की नियत और नीतियों में Face with stuck-out tongue and winking eyeFace with stuck-out tongue and winking eyeFace with stuck-out tongue and winking eye सवालों से वो घबराता है जिसके मन में चोर हो । Smiling face with smiling eyes अच्छा लगे तो सवा सौ करोड़ भाइयों-बहनों-मित्तरों से शेयर कीजिएSmiling face with smiling eyes"|#hi#|| more
Jan 06
