Tolerance to Non Performance by Swati Chaturvedi
Both Yogi Adityanath, chief minister of India's largest state Uttar Pradesh, and ML Khattar, chief minister of Haryana, have several things in common.
Both have zero administrative experience — the price for which is being paid by the blood of little children in UP as the horrific deaths in the BRD hospital continue unabated (61 children died again in the BRD college in the past 72 hours), and Khattar's serial mishandling of three major crises during his tenure, which has led to the death of nearly a 100 people.
The latest being the violence that set Haryana on the edge as 36 people died in the rioting that wrecked the state after Gurmeet Ram Rahim Singh was convicted of rape last Friday.
Last year, Khattar had mishandled the Jat quota agitation, which led to 30 deaths in three days as Haryana burnt. Before that, another cult head Rampal had a violent standoff with Haryana police in 2014, when six people died.
The other commonality the two greenhorn administrators share is that they have been anointed to their jobs by Prime Minister Narendra Modi. It is at the insistence of the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS), the Sangh Parivar mothership, that "normalising" the Sangh cadre in top jobs in the government is going on, and that is the reason for imposing Sangh full-timers (pracharaks) at crucial positions, such as CMs.
The RSS has decreed that pracharaks need to be in public life irrespective of the consequences.
I spoke to several BJP and RSS leaders while researching for this piece, and RSS leaders had a steadfast belief that a full-time pracharak could do any political and administrative job with absolute competence. Currently, the country is paying a price for this core belief but, it is an article of faith with the Sangh that cannot be trifled with.
That, along with perhaps the steadfast refusal of the various BJP-led governments to accept any mistakes on their part which would entail a sacking and thereby an admission of incompetence, has saved their jobs.
The RSS, which was shunned and treated like a pariah for many decades since Independence, is now revelling in its ascendancy at the top of the political structure. It has its man in Rashtrapati Bhavan, while the vice president is M Venkaiah Naidu – a former RSS full-timer, who has described Modi as an "avatar of God" and the BJP as his "mother". The sense of arrival will be complete when the last edifice of the Nehruvian structure – the bureaucracy – is made to submit to its cadres.
Similar is the insistence that all foreign dignitaries who come to India pay a ritual visit to the RSS-founded and Ram Madhav-led India Foundation, which is constantly organising seminars and dinners for visiting heads of state. It's completely mandatory for the cabinet to be in attendance and the invitees don't really have the option of saying no. This is also normalising the RSS as part of the diplomatic establishment, in fact putting it at the heart of India’s consular outreach.
The process of jobs for these “RSS boys” is ironically an imitation of the earlier establishment created by the Congress, which PM Modi, with his self-professed disdain for "Lutyens’ Delhi", has sworn to dismantle. Instead, the Sangh has created its own. So Khattar, despite his serial missteps, will always be safe as the RSS has too much invested into its "project pracharak".
The RSS view dovetails with the Modi-Shah requirements of subordinating the cadre-based BJP to their own larger-than-life image. Lacking any base of his own, Khattar, a first-time MLA, could not have believed in his wildest dreams that he would lead Haryana. For him, Modi and Shah are the last words, in sharp contrast to mass-based full-time politicians in the BJP fold, such as the three-term Madhya Pradesh CM Shivraj Singh Chouhan, as well as Rajasthan CM Vasundhara Raje – both of whom are not nearly so amenable.
The sense of Modi as a superman looming over a dwarfed and diminutive cabinet which feeds into the "Super Modi" narrative is evident in the significant gaps in the Union cabinet. You have the finance minister, Arun Jaitley doubling up as defence minister for months now. Similarly, Naidu's portfolio of information and broadcasting has been assigned to Smriti Irani, who holds the textiles ministry. Dr Harsh Vardhan has been given additional charge of environment, along with science and technology.
While vague whispers of cabinet reshuffle do the rounds and is likely to happen soon to accommodate new allies the BJP is getting, the message that gets across is that Modi does not need anyone. Far from the PM being the first among equals on which our cabinet system is based, PM Modi has no equal. The message is again of the singularity of a man on a mission without unnecessary systems bogging his exceptionalism down.
Modi is now the message and the medium to ensure that BJP wins elections, as was the case in Uttar Pradesh. Yogi Adityanath was sprung on the public after the BJP win. While Modi had talked of good governance, Adityanath stuck to his own agenda and bogus communal narratives, including Romeo squads, love jihad, the debunked Hindu exodus from Kairana, shutting down abattoirs and ensuring heavenly conditions for cows.
After the first tragedy struck Gorakhpur in which more than 50 children died, Adityanath, the incumbent five-term MP from Gorakhpur, wanted "Krishna Janamasthami" celebrated with "pomp and ceremony across governments in UP". He blamed everyone except himself and his government for the death of the little children.
Modi, an MP from Varanasi, kept mum on the tragedy except for an anodyne reference in passing during his Sunday radio show Mann Ki Baat. This, in a state which gave BJP a record haul of 73 out of 80 seats in the 2014 Lok Sabha elections, and 325 out of 403 Assembly seats in the state elections held earlier this year.
The only administrative experience that Adityanath has is running his math and his private militia: the Hindu Yuva Vahini (HYV) set up with a proclaimed aim of safeguarding Hindu interests. The HYV had last year petitioned that the cow be declared "rashtra mata" (national mother).
Adityanath's polarising personality, with his track record of serious criminal cases and hate speeches, suits the BJP perfectly for the big fight of 2019, where Shah expects that majoritarian muscle-flexing and disenfranchising the Muslims who constitute 19 percent of UP electorate will result in a record haul of seats as it did in the Assembly elections.
So, it's teflon Yogi till 2019. No accountability, and certainly as in the case of Khattar, no action against him. more
Both have zero administrative experience — the price for which is being paid by the blood of little children in UP as the horrific deaths in the BRD hospital continue unabated (61 children died again in the BRD college in the past 72 hours), and Khattar's serial mishandling of three major crises during his tenure, which has led to the death of nearly a 100 people.
The latest being the violence that set Haryana on the edge as 36 people died in the rioting that wrecked the state after Gurmeet Ram Rahim Singh was convicted of rape last Friday.
Last year, Khattar had mishandled the Jat quota agitation, which led to 30 deaths in three days as Haryana burnt. Before that, another cult head Rampal had a violent standoff with Haryana police in 2014, when six people died.
The other commonality the two greenhorn administrators share is that they have been anointed to their jobs by Prime Minister Narendra Modi. It is at the insistence of the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS), the Sangh Parivar mothership, that "normalising" the Sangh cadre in top jobs in the government is going on, and that is the reason for imposing Sangh full-timers (pracharaks) at crucial positions, such as CMs.
The RSS has decreed that pracharaks need to be in public life irrespective of the consequences.
I spoke to several BJP and RSS leaders while researching for this piece, and RSS leaders had a steadfast belief that a full-time pracharak could do any political and administrative job with absolute competence. Currently, the country is paying a price for this core belief but, it is an article of faith with the Sangh that cannot be trifled with.
That, along with perhaps the steadfast refusal of the various BJP-led governments to accept any mistakes on their part which would entail a sacking and thereby an admission of incompetence, has saved their jobs.
The RSS, which was shunned and treated like a pariah for many decades since Independence, is now revelling in its ascendancy at the top of the political structure. It has its man in Rashtrapati Bhavan, while the vice president is M Venkaiah Naidu – a former RSS full-timer, who has described Modi as an "avatar of God" and the BJP as his "mother". The sense of arrival will be complete when the last edifice of the Nehruvian structure – the bureaucracy – is made to submit to its cadres.
Similar is the insistence that all foreign dignitaries who come to India pay a ritual visit to the RSS-founded and Ram Madhav-led India Foundation, which is constantly organising seminars and dinners for visiting heads of state. It's completely mandatory for the cabinet to be in attendance and the invitees don't really have the option of saying no. This is also normalising the RSS as part of the diplomatic establishment, in fact putting it at the heart of India’s consular outreach.
The process of jobs for these “RSS boys” is ironically an imitation of the earlier establishment created by the Congress, which PM Modi, with his self-professed disdain for "Lutyens’ Delhi", has sworn to dismantle. Instead, the Sangh has created its own. So Khattar, despite his serial missteps, will always be safe as the RSS has too much invested into its "project pracharak".
The RSS view dovetails with the Modi-Shah requirements of subordinating the cadre-based BJP to their own larger-than-life image. Lacking any base of his own, Khattar, a first-time MLA, could not have believed in his wildest dreams that he would lead Haryana. For him, Modi and Shah are the last words, in sharp contrast to mass-based full-time politicians in the BJP fold, such as the three-term Madhya Pradesh CM Shivraj Singh Chouhan, as well as Rajasthan CM Vasundhara Raje – both of whom are not nearly so amenable.
The sense of Modi as a superman looming over a dwarfed and diminutive cabinet which feeds into the "Super Modi" narrative is evident in the significant gaps in the Union cabinet. You have the finance minister, Arun Jaitley doubling up as defence minister for months now. Similarly, Naidu's portfolio of information and broadcasting has been assigned to Smriti Irani, who holds the textiles ministry. Dr Harsh Vardhan has been given additional charge of environment, along with science and technology.
While vague whispers of cabinet reshuffle do the rounds and is likely to happen soon to accommodate new allies the BJP is getting, the message that gets across is that Modi does not need anyone. Far from the PM being the first among equals on which our cabinet system is based, PM Modi has no equal. The message is again of the singularity of a man on a mission without unnecessary systems bogging his exceptionalism down.
Modi is now the message and the medium to ensure that BJP wins elections, as was the case in Uttar Pradesh. Yogi Adityanath was sprung on the public after the BJP win. While Modi had talked of good governance, Adityanath stuck to his own agenda and bogus communal narratives, including Romeo squads, love jihad, the debunked Hindu exodus from Kairana, shutting down abattoirs and ensuring heavenly conditions for cows.
After the first tragedy struck Gorakhpur in which more than 50 children died, Adityanath, the incumbent five-term MP from Gorakhpur, wanted "Krishna Janamasthami" celebrated with "pomp and ceremony across governments in UP". He blamed everyone except himself and his government for the death of the little children.
Modi, an MP from Varanasi, kept mum on the tragedy except for an anodyne reference in passing during his Sunday radio show Mann Ki Baat. This, in a state which gave BJP a record haul of 73 out of 80 seats in the 2014 Lok Sabha elections, and 325 out of 403 Assembly seats in the state elections held earlier this year.
The only administrative experience that Adityanath has is running his math and his private militia: the Hindu Yuva Vahini (HYV) set up with a proclaimed aim of safeguarding Hindu interests. The HYV had last year petitioned that the cow be declared "rashtra mata" (national mother).
Adityanath's polarising personality, with his track record of serious criminal cases and hate speeches, suits the BJP perfectly for the big fight of 2019, where Shah expects that majoritarian muscle-flexing and disenfranchising the Muslims who constitute 19 percent of UP electorate will result in a record haul of seats as it did in the Assembly elections.
So, it's teflon Yogi till 2019. No accountability, and certainly as in the case of Khattar, no action against him. more
Viewed by 380
View all 6 comments Below 6 comments
The problem with these congress people is that they think only congress has all experience. What experience does sonia or rahul have?. The handling of Ram Rahim matter was well handled keeping in view the intent of his followers to create mayhem in Panchkula ( came fully armed). Similarly the deaths at gorakhpur have been happening foe many years but no one highlighted it . Now since BJP is in power so the attempt to malign it more
Sep 25
Ruchika ji, I find peculiar comments from you saying a government or Chief Ministers who is presently governing the State is responsible for each and every thing. Administration has been made poor over a long period and all the previous governments have to own such responsibilities. In case some thing is deliberately done wrong by a new government one can blame otherwise it is lacking administration, as such. more
Aug 31
Is this swati a pseduo name of swati maliwal. Or some inner cabinet of most corroupt politician in India dear Kejribaba. Circle is Make Delhi better with Kejriwal whose only contribution to Delhi is institutionalising corrouption without taking any responsibility. Total AAP has zero admin experience... as i dare kejribaba to even put on record even a single decision as IRS officer before asking his proxies to raise fingers on others. Only a few days ago Kejribhai said he and his party will just be limiting their activities (including nefarious activities may be) to Delhi And moment his party has won Bawana by bribing voters ..this post. Fact is Khattar dared to take head on highly connected and hugely popular Dera chief . Which so called experienced politicians of RLD and Congress viz Chautala and Hudda never ever thought of or were accomplice in Dera activities. Second time in row a very small section of Haryana's bureacracy and police administration tried in vain to protect their vested interests and only acumen of Khattar could neutralise black sheep. Jat Agitation was intentionally and delibrately started by congress to divide Haryana society which was first in country to shed caste. In Delhi in 3 years more than 10 have died in cleaning sewers. Each and every development action is standstill. At most of foot overbridges lifts r not installed though money swindled. Foot over bridge at starting point at Vikaspuri is incomplete for 3 years. Barapulla flyover is going signature bridge way And 99.99% of AAP doing only paap of corrouption and taking Delhi behind tier 3 cities of even Bihar. So request to circle manager first issue directions to these vested politicians of AAp to concentrate on Delhi. C the beauty of kejribhai selection criteria First law minister wss a law unto himself ... just extracting money from foreigners in mid night raids. 2nd law minister was master of frauds that he invented his own degree. Transport minister has swallowed buses of delhi and buses on roads has decreased by 25% Four to five lakh e ricksaws have not paid road tax of nearly 2250 crores and aap is extracting similar amount in cash from them. I suggest let this amount be recovered from kejribhai personally as it is his proven administeation failure and corrouption encouragement. Reduction in buses and mush rooming of e ricksaws has led to cost of transportation being twice. Grameen sewas take 12-14 persons as if we r cattle So let Swati and her ilk visit Delhi and guide their mentor kejribhai to stop corrouption and do Delhi improvement. Otherwise not only Delhites will ditch Kejribhai even his wife may ditch him when all his double speak (as of dera chief) become public info. more
Aug 31
Strange behavior by Center. It appears they protect their own kind regardless of failures. Bad politics, to say the least. more
Aug 31
