Why Modi won't further Ram Mandir
One of the worries that baiters of Narendra Modi had that if he became the prime minister, then the contentious Ram Mandir at Ayodhya would become a reality and split the nation into two. Those fears are far-fetched because Modi is going to do absolutely nothing on the Ram Mandir issue.
Here is why...
1. Modi did absolutely nothing for major Hindu causes in Gujarat.
Modi was accused of letting Hindu hardliners go on the rampage during the Godhra riots and then in the subsequent elections derided the Muslim community with the comment, "Hum paanch hamare pachees" during campaigning. However, the former charge did not hold up in courts and as far as the latter is concerned, Modi didn't make such an inflammatory statement ever again.
He totally harnessed the development mantra in Gujarat, clipped the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh's (RSS) wings and went on a confrontational path with the Vishwa Hindu Parishad (VHP), making an arch enemy out of the firebrand Pravin Togadia, who hates Modi to this very day for that.
For example, did you know that at one of the Sangh Parivar gatherings in Gujarat in 2007, Modi was blasted as being anti-Hindu! Another point to note is that among BJP leaders, Arun Shourie has written the most on Islamic issues while Subramanian Swamy speaks the most hardline Hindutva language.
Do you think it's a coincidence that both found themselves out of the Modi Cabinet in 2014?
When Modi hasn't taken up even smaller Hindutva/VHP/RSS causes directly, what hope is there for the biggest one of them all in the form of the Ram Mandir?
2. Modi can't afford a confrontation with the Supreme Court.
While the Supreme Court has been open to discussing cow slaughter and uniform civil code, that has not been the case with the Ram Mandir.
The Allahabad High Court's verdict came in 2010, while the Supreme Court ruled in 2013 that a status quo be maintained till the appeals are dealt with. Currently the ball is in the Supreme Court and nobody, not even Modi, can do anything till the verdict comes. It's anybody's guess when that will be!
3. BJP doesn't have two-thirds majority in the Lok Sabha and is in the pits in the Rajya Sabha.
If Modi wants to pre-empt the Supreme Court or overrule it if the verdict goes against what is desired, then the BJP will require two-thirds majority in both Houses. Currently it has just above 50 per cent in the Lok Sabha and has an abysmal presence in the Rajya Sabha.
Modi even had to scrap his Land Bill. A case in the point is also the Goods and Services Tax (GST) Bill. That has broad-based consensus throughout the country and yet Modi is absolutely struggling to pass it! So what hope is there for a highly contentious issue like Ram Mandir?
4. Delhi and Bihar election losses, #AwardWapsi and #Intolerance has put Modi on the back foot.
The BJP will push for the Ram Mandir only in two contrasting scenarios. One if it's firmly on the front foot. Or when all is lost and it takes the issue up as a desperate gamble. Currently the party is on the back foot following election defeats in Delhi and Bihar, and #AwardWapsi and #Intolerance campaigns.
However, all is not lost. The Modi government is marching ahead with his reforms of power, railways and infrastructure sectors, and with the #ToiletRevolution, and will not want to be bogged down by the Ram Mandir imbroglio.
5. Modi-RSS ties are not all hunky-dory.
It is laughable that some have said that Modi is being remote controlled by the RSS. That is not the case. Modi is his own man and shares an uneasy relationship with RSS leadership. In fact, it is for this reason that both the RSS and BJP leadership opposed him in 2013.
The RSS leadership is furious that Modi is refusing to take up any of their pet issues and his relationship with the VHP has been really bad for ages now.
6. He will not touch "Mission 2017" too.
Here's a conspiracy theory. The Sangh Parivar will push for the Ram Mandir in the 2017 Uttar Pradesh Assembly elections and thereby polarise the electorate and capture power in the state and use it as a launching pad for further consolidation in 2019!
However, there's a serious flaw in that. 2017 is when the BJP will get its own President and vice-president who will head the Rajya Sabha. For the first time ever, the BJP is the largest party in the electoral college and just needs a little push to secure both posts.
There's no way Modi is going to jeopardise that!
7. None of the issues of the far-right will be taken up.
Another important point is that Modi has positioned himself at centre-right. None of the issues of the far-right will be taken up, like scrapping of Article 370 and uniform civil code, where even the courts are making more progress than Modi!
The far-right also wants Modi to take on the mainstream media and promote Hinduism aggressively, none of which is happening.
8. All Sangh Parivar hardliners turn moderate in the end.
AB Vajpayee as a hardliner used to make strong Hindutva speeches and made one even when the Ram Mandir movement was underway. As prime minister he became quite mellow. LK Advani led a rath yatra that eventually led to the demolishing of the Babri Masjid.
Today he is the darling of the seculars. Sangh Parivar leaders do a lot in their hardline phases and mellow down thereafter. Modi was seen as a rank hardliner in 2002 and fashioned himself as a statesman from 2007 onwards.He has come too far with his "governance and development" image in 2015 to touch the Ram Mandir.
Post script...
The idols mysteriously appeared in the Ram Mandir when Jawaharlal Nehru was the prime minister, the locks were opened when Rajiv Gandhi was the prime minister and the masjid came down when PV Narasimha Rao was the prime minister. All Congress regimes! more
Here is why...
1. Modi did absolutely nothing for major Hindu causes in Gujarat.
Modi was accused of letting Hindu hardliners go on the rampage during the Godhra riots and then in the subsequent elections derided the Muslim community with the comment, "Hum paanch hamare pachees" during campaigning. However, the former charge did not hold up in courts and as far as the latter is concerned, Modi didn't make such an inflammatory statement ever again.
He totally harnessed the development mantra in Gujarat, clipped the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh's (RSS) wings and went on a confrontational path with the Vishwa Hindu Parishad (VHP), making an arch enemy out of the firebrand Pravin Togadia, who hates Modi to this very day for that.
For example, did you know that at one of the Sangh Parivar gatherings in Gujarat in 2007, Modi was blasted as being anti-Hindu! Another point to note is that among BJP leaders, Arun Shourie has written the most on Islamic issues while Subramanian Swamy speaks the most hardline Hindutva language.
Do you think it's a coincidence that both found themselves out of the Modi Cabinet in 2014?
When Modi hasn't taken up even smaller Hindutva/VHP/RSS causes directly, what hope is there for the biggest one of them all in the form of the Ram Mandir?
2. Modi can't afford a confrontation with the Supreme Court.
While the Supreme Court has been open to discussing cow slaughter and uniform civil code, that has not been the case with the Ram Mandir.
The Allahabad High Court's verdict came in 2010, while the Supreme Court ruled in 2013 that a status quo be maintained till the appeals are dealt with. Currently the ball is in the Supreme Court and nobody, not even Modi, can do anything till the verdict comes. It's anybody's guess when that will be!
3. BJP doesn't have two-thirds majority in the Lok Sabha and is in the pits in the Rajya Sabha.
If Modi wants to pre-empt the Supreme Court or overrule it if the verdict goes against what is desired, then the BJP will require two-thirds majority in both Houses. Currently it has just above 50 per cent in the Lok Sabha and has an abysmal presence in the Rajya Sabha.
Modi even had to scrap his Land Bill. A case in the point is also the Goods and Services Tax (GST) Bill. That has broad-based consensus throughout the country and yet Modi is absolutely struggling to pass it! So what hope is there for a highly contentious issue like Ram Mandir?
4. Delhi and Bihar election losses, #AwardWapsi and #Intolerance has put Modi on the back foot.
The BJP will push for the Ram Mandir only in two contrasting scenarios. One if it's firmly on the front foot. Or when all is lost and it takes the issue up as a desperate gamble. Currently the party is on the back foot following election defeats in Delhi and Bihar, and #AwardWapsi and #Intolerance campaigns.
However, all is not lost. The Modi government is marching ahead with his reforms of power, railways and infrastructure sectors, and with the #ToiletRevolution, and will not want to be bogged down by the Ram Mandir imbroglio.
5. Modi-RSS ties are not all hunky-dory.
It is laughable that some have said that Modi is being remote controlled by the RSS. That is not the case. Modi is his own man and shares an uneasy relationship with RSS leadership. In fact, it is for this reason that both the RSS and BJP leadership opposed him in 2013.
The RSS leadership is furious that Modi is refusing to take up any of their pet issues and his relationship with the VHP has been really bad for ages now.
6. He will not touch "Mission 2017" too.
Here's a conspiracy theory. The Sangh Parivar will push for the Ram Mandir in the 2017 Uttar Pradesh Assembly elections and thereby polarise the electorate and capture power in the state and use it as a launching pad for further consolidation in 2019!
However, there's a serious flaw in that. 2017 is when the BJP will get its own President and vice-president who will head the Rajya Sabha. For the first time ever, the BJP is the largest party in the electoral college and just needs a little push to secure both posts.
There's no way Modi is going to jeopardise that!
7. None of the issues of the far-right will be taken up.
Another important point is that Modi has positioned himself at centre-right. None of the issues of the far-right will be taken up, like scrapping of Article 370 and uniform civil code, where even the courts are making more progress than Modi!
The far-right also wants Modi to take on the mainstream media and promote Hinduism aggressively, none of which is happening.
8. All Sangh Parivar hardliners turn moderate in the end.
AB Vajpayee as a hardliner used to make strong Hindutva speeches and made one even when the Ram Mandir movement was underway. As prime minister he became quite mellow. LK Advani led a rath yatra that eventually led to the demolishing of the Babri Masjid.
Today he is the darling of the seculars. Sangh Parivar leaders do a lot in their hardline phases and mellow down thereafter. Modi was seen as a rank hardliner in 2002 and fashioned himself as a statesman from 2007 onwards.He has come too far with his "governance and development" image in 2015 to touch the Ram Mandir.
Post script...
The idols mysteriously appeared in the Ram Mandir when Jawaharlal Nehru was the prime minister, the locks were opened when Rajiv Gandhi was the prime minister and the masjid came down when PV Narasimha Rao was the prime minister. All Congress regimes! more
Viewed by 1810
View all 6 comments Below 6 comments
What is the so called harassment to middle class. There is a gradual reduction in personnel income tax which will be furthered in the coming years. Make in India is vigorously pursued and due course of time with injection of private investment employment will improve. With lot of start up companies the starting pay scale in most of the major engineering and management institutes have gone up substantially. What else you want for middle class. more
Dec 02
Modi government is all out to harass middle class who voted him with majority expecting better then congress govt be it finance minister or any other ministry are coming with levies or taxes only to make our life miserable then helping in any tax rebate or otherwise.I still have 100% confident in capabilities of PM and waiting for some thunderous news which will turn table in his favor till then it is better for all ministers MPs and other leaders of the party to behave in nice manner . They do not have any creditable achievement to display/ boost. Religious and social harmony of the highest order shall be maintained by act or speeches at all levels of party. more
Dec 02
Modi so far has been a total failure in every front whether it is containing Corruption,inflation ,black money or development.He is mostly seen by the people who voted for him in 2014 as a megalomaniac narcissistic liar.Full of gas and explosions on "Mann ki Baat"but hardly any progresson on real"Kaam ki baat"in last 20 months. more
Dec 02
